|
Professional Reviews...
Royal Navy & Maritime Book
Reviews
Please click:
Over By Christmas
Comments by Readers...
"Brilliant
story of love, political intrigue and world
war."
"At last, a
magnificent work of romance and war
by a British author who knows what
he's writing about. Ex-Royal Navy
officer William Daysh has captured
the sweep and vastness of World War
One sea battles, when the English
Navy was supreme and Germany was
determined to destroy it. His
wonderfully-described scenes of
thunderous naval duels are
counterpoint to a story of
unrequited (or is it?) love between
the British Prime Minister and the
young Venetia Stanley, an
emotionally-ripping affair that
caught him just as Britain was going
to war in 1914. From the book: 'The
direction of Britain's war effort
was...in the hands of decision
makers wracked by divisive argument,
led by a lovelorn Prime Minister
plagued by emotional distractions.'
"It is the story also of a young
Royal Navy gunner coming of age
through intense tragedy and his own
journey through life, love, and
heart-breaking loss. Daysh's combat
scenes on land and at sea are some
of the very best I have ever read,
the tender moments among the
principals are lovely, and his gift
for details and dialogue make 'Over
By Christmas' a splendid adventure.
A grand tale such as this is the
result of masterly talent and,
without question, extensive research
and dedication to crafting a
terrific book. I won't give away the
surprising ending but I cannot wait
for 'OBC II'! It's fun to imagine
what actors will play which parts
when 'Over By Christmas' comes to
the big screen, as it truly
deserves."
Don Struke,
Baltimore, MD USA, 26 April 2008
Over
by Christmas...
"This
book is a fascinating account of the First World
War at sea. We are constantly informed about
life in the trenches but little is said about
this aspect of the war. Excellent research,
good characterisation, he captures the
(difficult to explain) relationships within
marriages where the stiff upper lip was
paramount in the older generation and they
didn't let their feelings show. All in all a
thumping good read, I couldn't put it down.
Would highly recommend."
Anon
Over
by Christmas...
"An incredibly well-written,
well-researched
book, made more interesting by the
way the
author has woven ordinary people’s
lives into
the story of the Great war and the
government of the day. I feel this
book would prove to be interesting and educative to
people who would normally not read
war
stories. The book moves rapidly from
one
aspect to another so the reader is
always
ready for more.
Personally I
thoroughly enjoyed the book;
I read it over two days and I must
congratulate the author on the
excellent
grammar, perfect spelling and
totally
believable cockney – hard for some
authors
to handle! The sexual scenes for
that era are
handled beautifully and I also
enjoyed the
Asquith chapters! Just shows you
what goes
on in our government! Talk about
Profumo
and Prescott!"
Anon
Over
by Christmas...
"I very much enjoy
historical novels, so was
particularly pleased to be able to
read this
one. I found it to be extremely
readable
and it gave me an insight to aspects
of the
First World War and life at home at
that
time which one hears little about. "
Anon
Over By
Christmas...
"This well researched
book describes life in the early
years of WW1. It is not as you might
think a boring history lesson but
looks at life and conditions as they
were during this period. There is a
love story that illustrates all too
clearly how little influence women
of that time held, leading to
Emmeline Pankhurst and her suffrage
movement. The Coronel Disaster where
two British battleships are sunk
with no survivors by a superior
German Fleet is brilliantly told and
must have the reader wondering how
these great ships which look
invincible when alongside in
Portsmouth Dockyard are really
nothing more than death traps. The
Gallipoli campaign is well told, in
particular the conversations at the
British Admiralty between Asquith,
Fisher, Churchill and others provide
a valuable background and
understanding as to why these
disasters occur. There is much much
more in this book which Bill writes
in his convincing and easy to read
style and the end came all too
quickly. Congratulations on a great
effort and put me on the list for
OBC2. "
Michael Power, Hobart, Tasmania,
Australia 11 May 2008
Over By Christmas...
"As a survivor of air combat over
Europe during World War Two, I think
I have some understanding of how my
father’s generation was affected by
the 1914-1918 cataclysm known as the
War to End All Wars. My father
luckily did not experience World War
One but had he been English rather
than American, he would have seen
many of his contemporaries in the
British military and government
caught up in questionable decisions
made by stubborn leaders. The
resulting loss of life, equipment
and ships is appalling, and the
author of Over By Christmas shows
how these leaders were unduly
influenced by those around them.
The story is told by following the
lives of people at the top of
government and people far below, who
in many cases were sacrificed and
sent to death by leaders who made
bad decisions without second
thoughts or vestige of remorse. You
will experience exciting
descriptions of German and English
battleships maneuvering while
shelling each other, and you’ll
witness the terror of the crews
while they fight to survive. The
realism of war at sea and on land at
Gallipoli is absolutely outstanding.
One of the major culprits, if I may
use that word, was the British prime
minister, who should have focused
totally on the future of his nation,
but was head-over-heels in love with
a woman young enough to be his
daughter, to the dismay of his wife.
The reader wishes he would spend
more time running the country and
less time writing letters to the
alluring lady. For the book’s young
Royal Navy gunner, George, and his
shipmates, their futures depend on
the courage required to keep going
forward in spite of the odds. The
continuing love story of George and
Carrie was finalized in a
bittersweet ending that was
different than most affairs of the
heart , and yet one could see that
it must end that way.
This is a fascinating book with a
lot of twists and turns, and
thoroughly enjoyable. "
Jim Skophammer, Lincoln,
California, USA, 03 June 2008
Over By Christmas...
"Over
By Christmas is about ordinary lives
set within major events during the
first two years of the First World
War which is so well researched that
it includes interesting, and little
known, detail about conditions
during that period. The story
includes a robust fictional cast of
characters together with prominent
contemporary politicians and senior
military personalities which has
been assembled into an entertaining
docu-drama which, having started to
read, is difficult to put down. The
story line, with the exception of
historical events, is not at all
predictable and the ending permits a
sequel which I hope will appear
soon. I enjoyed this book and have
no hesitation in recommending it as
an excellent read."
Harold Jemmett, Fleet,
Hampshire, UK, 05 July 2008
Over By Christmas...
"This is a beautifully crafted
story, expertly interweaving the
main fictional characters into the
political and social mores at the
time of the 1914-18 War. William
Daysh has used publicly available
data and personal papers to tell a
poignant tale of love between George
Royal, a young Naval rating and
Carrie, a young girl of the servant
class. He contrasts this with the
sugar-daddy and passionate affair
between the British Prime Minister
and the young and inexperienced
Venetia Stanley.
George's friend Bill Guy first meets
and falls in love with Carrie, but
she also has eyes for George. The
machinations of this triangle,
interwoven with expert and vivid
descriptions of sea battles and the
doomed Dardanelles 'adventure', show
the author to have an instinctive
sympathy with those serving in the
armed forces and facing death. This
is an enthralling book."
Mr. B. Wright "Book Wright",
Colchester, Essex, UK, 06 July 2008
Over By Christmas...
"Finished Over By Christmas; WELL
DONE! I have really enjoyed it.
So nice to see some proper English
words used. Claudia wants it next,
then Maggie for her book club.
I feel privileged and proud that a
friend of mine has written such a
good book.
Well done for spelling Pearse the
right way!"
Malcolm Pearse,
Hertforshire, UK, 11 July 2008
|